CHAPTERI。
TheStateofGreecefromtheearliestTimestotheCommencementofthePeloponnesianWarTHUCYDIDES,anAthenian,wrotethehistoryofthewarbetweenthePeloponnesiansandtheAthenians,beginningatthemomentthatitbrokeout,andbelievingthatitwouldbeagreatwarandmoreworthyofrelationthananythathadprecededit。Thisbeliefwasnotwithoutitsgrounds。Thepreparationsofboththecombatantswereineverydepartmentinthelaststateofperfection;andhecouldseetherestoftheHellenicracetakingsidesinthequarrel;thosewhodelayeddoingsoatoncehavingitincontemplation。Indeedthiswasthegreatestmovementyetknowninhistory,notonlyoftheHellenes,butofalargepartofthebarbarianworld-Ihadalmostsaidofmankind。Forthoughtheeventsofremoteantiquity,andeventhosethatmoreimmediatelyprecededthewar,couldnotfromlapseoftimebeclearlyascertained,yettheevidenceswhichaninquirycarriedasfarbackaswaspracticableleadsmetotrust,allpointtotheconclusionthattherewasnothingonagreatscale,eitherinwarorinothermatters。
Forinstance,itisevidentthatthecountrynowcalledHellashadinancienttimesnosettledpopulation;onthecontrary,migrationswereoffrequentoccurrence,theseveraltribesreadilyabandoningtheirhomesunderthepressureofsuperiornumbers。Withoutcommerce,withoutfreedomofcommunicationeitherbylandorsea,cultivatingnomoreoftheirterritorythantheexigenciesofliferequired,destituteofcapital,neverplantingtheirland(fortheycouldnottellwhenaninvadermightnotcomeandtakeitallaway,andwhenhedidcometheyhadnowallstostophim),thinkingthatthenecessitiesofdailysustenancecouldbesuppliedatoneplaceaswellasanother,theycaredlittleforshiftingtheirhabitation,andconsequentlyneitherbuiltlargecitiesnorattainedtoanyotherformofgreatness。Therichestsoilswerealwaysmostsubjecttothischangeofmasters;suchasthedistrictnowcalledThessaly,Boeotia,mostofthePeloponnese,Arcadiaexcepted,andthemostfertilepartsoftherestofHellas。Thegoodnessofthelandfavouredtheaggrandizementofparticularindividuals,andthuscreatedfactionwhichprovedafertilesourceofruin。Italsoinvitedinvasion。
AccordinglyAttica,fromthepovertyofitssoilenjoyingfromaveryremoteperiodfreedomfromfaction,neverchangeditsinhabitants。Andhereisnoinconsiderableexemplificationofmyassertionthatthemigrationswerethecauseoftherebeingnocorrespondentgrowthinotherparts。ThemostpowerfulvictimsofwarorfactionfromtherestofHellastookrefugewiththeAtheniansasasaferetreat;andatanearlyperiod,becomingnaturalized,swelledthealreadylargepopulationofthecitytosuchaheightthatAtticabecameatlasttoosmalltoholdthem,andtheyhadtosendoutcoloniestoIonia。
Thereisalsoanothercircumstancethatcontributesnotalittletomyconvictionoftheweaknessofancienttimes。BeforetheTrojanwarthereisnoindicationofanycommonactioninHellas,norindeedoftheuniversalprevalenceofthename;onthecontrary,beforethetimeofHellen,sonofDeucalion,nosuchappellationexisted,butthecountrywentbythenamesofthedifferenttribes,inparticularofthePelasgian。ItwasnottillHellenandhissonsgrewstronginPhthiotis,andwereinvitedasalliesintotheothercities,thatonebyonetheygraduallyacquiredfromtheconnectionthenameofHellenes;thoughalongtimeelapsedbeforethatnamecouldfastenitselfuponall。ThebestproofofthisisfurnishedbyHomer。BornlongaftertheTrojanWar,henowherecallsallofthembythatname,norindeedanyofthemexceptthefollowersofAchillesfromPhthiotis,whoweretheoriginalHellenes:inhispoemstheyarecalledDanaans,Argives,andAchaeans。Hedoesnotevenusethetermbarbarian,probablybecausetheHelleneshadnotyetbeenmarkedofffromtherestoftheworldbyonedistinctiveappellation。ItappearsthereforethattheseveralHelleniccommunities,comprisingnotonlythosewhofirstacquiredthename,citybycity,astheycametounderstandeachother,butalsothosewhoassumeditafterwardsasthenameofthewholepeople,werebeforetheTrojanwarpreventedbytheirwantofstrengthandtheabsenceofmutualintercoursefromdisplayinganycollectiveaction。
Indeed,theycouldnotuniteforthisexpeditiontilltheyhadgainedincreasedfamiliaritywiththesea。AndthefirstpersonknowntousbytraditionashavingestablishedanavyisMinos。HemadehimselfmasterofwhatisnowcalledtheHellenicsea,andruledovertheCyclades,intomostofwhichhesentthefirstcolonies,expellingtheCariansandappointinghisownsonsgovernors;
andthusdidhisbesttoputdownpiracyinthosewaters,anecessarysteptosecuretherevenuesforhisownuse。
ForinearlytimestheHellenesandthebarbariansofthecoastandislands,ascommunicationbyseabecamemorecommon,weretemptedtoturnpirates,undertheconductoftheirmostpowerfulmen;
themotivesbeingtoservetheirowncupidityandtosupporttheneedy。Theywouldfalluponatownunprotectedbywalls,andconsistingofamerecollectionofvillages,andwouldplunderit;
indeed,thiscametobethemainsourceoftheirlivelihood,nodisgracebeingyetattachedtosuchanachievement,butevensomeglory。Anillustrationofthisisfurnishedbythehonourwithwhichsomeoftheinhabitantsofthecontinentstillregardasuccessfulmarauder,andbythequestionwefindtheoldpoetseverywhererepresentingthepeopleasaskingofvoyagers-"Aretheypirates?"-
asifthosewhoareaskedthequestionwouldhavenoideaofdisclaimingtheimputation,ortheirinterrogatorsofreproachingthemforit。Thesamerapineprevailedalsobyland。
AndevenatthepresentdaymanyofHellasstillfollowtheoldfashion,theOzolianLocriansforinstance,theAetolians,theAcarnanians,andthatregionofthecontinent;andthecustomofcarryingarmsisstillkeptupamongthesecontinentals,fromtheoldpiraticalhabits。ThewholeofHellasusedoncetocarryarms,theirhabitationsbeingunprotectedandtheircommunicationwitheachotherunsafe;indeed,toweararmswasasmuchapartofeverydaylifewiththemaswiththebarbarians。AndthefactthatthepeopleinthesepartsofHellasarestilllivingintheoldwaypointstoatimewhenthesamemodeoflifewasonceequallycommontoall。TheAthenianswerethefirsttolayasidetheirweapons,andtoadoptaneasierandmoreluxuriousmodeoflife;indeed,itisonlylatelythattheirricholdmenleftofftheluxuryofwearingundergarmentsoflinen,andfasteningaknotoftheirhairwithatieofgoldengrasshoppers,afashionwhichspreadtotheirIoniankindredandlongprevailedamongtheoldmenthere。Onthecontrary,amodeststyleofdressing,moreinconformitywithmodernideas,wasfirstadoptedbytheLacedaemonians,therichdoingtheirbesttoassimilatetheirwayoflifetothatofthecommonpeople。Theyalsosettheexampleofcontendingnaked,publiclystrippingandanointingthemselveswithoilintheirgymnasticexercises。Formerly,evenintheOlympiccontests,theathleteswhocontendedworebeltsacrosstheirmiddles;anditisbutafewyearssincethatthepracticeceased。Tothisdayamongsomeofthebarbarians,especiallyinAsia,whenprizesforboxingandwrestlingareoffered,beltsarewornbythecombatants。AndtherearemanyotherpointsinwhichalikenessmightbeshownbetweenthelifeoftheHellenicworldofoldandthebarbarianofto-day。
Withrespecttotheirtowns,lateron,ataneraofincreasedfacilitiesofnavigationandagreatersupplyofcapital,wefindtheshoresbecomingthesiteofwalledtowns,andtheisthmusesbeingoccupiedforthepurposesofcommerceanddefenceagainstaneighbour。Buttheoldtowns,onaccountofthegreatprevalenceofpiracy,werebuiltawayfromthesea,whetherontheislandsorthecontinent,andstillremainintheiroldsites。Forthepiratesusedtoplunderoneanother,andindeedallcoastpopulations,whetherseafaringornot。
Theislanders,too,weregreatpirates。TheseislanderswereCariansandPhoenicians,bywhommostoftheislandswerecolonized,aswasprovedbythefollowingfact。DuringthepurificationofDelosbyAthensinthiswarallthegravesintheislandweretakenup,anditwasfoundthatabovehalftheirinmateswereCarians:theywereidentifiedbythefashionofthearmsburiedwiththem,andbythemethodofinterment,whichwasthesameastheCariansstillfollow。
ButassoonasMinoshadformedhisnavy,communicationbyseabecameeasier,ashecolonizedmostoftheislands,andthusexpelledthemalefactors。Thecoastpopulationnowbegantoapplythemselvesmorecloselytotheacquisitionofwealth,andtheirlifebecamemoresettled;someevenbegantobuildthemselveswallsonthestrengthoftheirnewlyacquiredriches。Fortheloveofgainwouldreconciletheweakertothedominionofthestronger,andthepossessionofcapitalenabledthemorepowerfultoreducethesmallertownstosubjection。AnditwasatasomewhatlaterstageofthisdevelopmentthattheywentontheexpeditionagainstTroy。
WhatenabledAgamemnontoraisethearmamentwasmore,inmyopinion,hissuperiorityinstrength,thantheoathsofTyndareus,whichboundthesuitorstofollowhim。Indeed,theaccountgivenbythosePeloponnesianswhohavebeentherecipientsofthemostcredibletraditionisthis。FirstofallPelops,arrivingamonganeedypopulationfromAsiawithvastwealth,acquiredsuchpowerthat,strangerthoughhewas,thecountrywascalledafterhim;andthispowerfortunesawfitmateriallytoincreaseinthehandsofhisdescendants。EurystheushadbeenkilledinAtticabytheHeraclids。
Atreuswashismother'sbrother;andtothehandsofhisrelation,whohadlefthisfatheronaccountofthedeathofChrysippus,Eurystheus,whenhesetoutonhisexpedition,hadcommittedMycenaeandthegovernment。AstimewentonandEurystheusdidnotreturn,AtreuscompliedwiththewishesoftheMycenaeans,whowereinfluencedbyfearoftheHeraclids-besides,hispowerseemedconsiderable,andhehadnotneglectedtocourtthefavourofthepopulace-andassumedthesceptreofMycenaeandtherestofthedominionsofEurystheus。
AndsothepowerofthedescendantsofPelopscametobegreaterthanthatofthedescendantsofPerseus。ToallthisAgamemnonsucceeded。Hehadalsoanavyfarstrongerthanhiscontemporaries,sothat,inmyopinion,fearwasquiteasstronganelementasloveintheformationoftheconfederateexpedition。Thestrengthofhisnavyisshownbythefactthathisownwasthelargestcontingent,andthatoftheArcadianswasfurnishedbyhim;thisatleastiswhatHomersays,ifhistestimonyisdeemedsufficient。Besides,inhisaccountofthetransmissionofthesceptre,hecallshimOfmanyanisle,andofallArgosking。
NowAgamemnon'swasacontinentalpower;andhecouldnothavebeenmasterofanyexcepttheadjacentislands(andthesewouldnotbemany),butthroughthepossessionofafleet。
Andfromthisexpeditionwemayinferthecharacterofearlierenterprises。NowMycenaemayhavebeenasmallplace,andmanyofthetownsofthatagemayappearcomparativelyinsignificant,butnoexactobserverwouldthereforefeeljustifiedinrejectingtheestimategivenbythepoetsandbytraditionofthemagnitudeofthearmament。ForIsupposeifLacedaemonweretobecomedesolate,andthetemplesandthefoundationsofthepublicbuildingswereleft,thatastimewentontherewouldbeastrongdispositionwithposteritytorefusetoacceptherfameasatrueexponentofherpower。Andyettheyoccupytwo-fifthsofPeloponneseandleadthewhole,nottospeakoftheirnumerousallieswithout。Still,asthecityisneitherbuiltinacompactformnoradornedwithmagnificenttemplesandpublicedifices,butcomposedofvillagesaftertheoldfashionofHellas,therewouldbeanimpressionofinadequacy。Whereas,ifAthensweretosufferthesamemisfortune,Isupposethatanyinferencefromtheappearancepresentedtotheeyewouldmakeherpowertohavebeentwiceasgreatasitis。Wehavethereforenorighttobesceptical,nortocontentourselveswithaninspectionofatowntotheexclusionofaconsiderationofitspower;butwemaysafelyconcludethatthearmamentinquestionsurpassedallbeforeit,asitfellshortofmodernefforts;ifwecanherealsoacceptthetestimonyofHomer'spoems,inwhich,withoutallowingfortheexaggerationwhichapoetwouldfeelhimselflicensedtoemploy,wecanseethatitwasfarfromequallingours。Hehasrepresenteditasconsistingoftwelvehundredvessels;theBoeotiancomplementofeachshipbeingahundredandtwentymen,thatoftheshipsofPhiloctetesfifty。Bythis,Iconceive,hemeanttoconveythemaximumandtheminimumcomplement:atanyrate,hedoesnotspecifytheamountofanyothersinhiscatalogueoftheships。ThattheywereallrowersaswellaswarriorsweseefromhisaccountoftheshipsofPhiloctetes,inwhichallthemenattheoararebowmen。Nowitisimprobablethatmanysupernumerariessailed,ifweexceptthekingsandhighofficers;especiallyastheyhadtocrosstheopenseawithmunitionsofwar,inships,moreover,thathadnodecks,butwereequippedintheoldpiraticalfashion。Sothatifwestriketheaverageofthelargestandsmallestships,thenumberofthosewhosailedwillappearinconsiderable,representing,astheydid,thewholeforceofHellas。Andthiswasduenotsomuchtoscarcityofmenasofmoney。Difficultyofsubsistencemadetheinvadersreducethenumbersofthearmytoapointatwhichitmightliveonthecountryduringtheprosecutionofthewar。Evenafterthevictorytheyobtainedontheirarrival-andavictorytheremusthavebeen,orthefortificationsofthenavalcampcouldneverhavebeenbuilt-thereisnoindicationoftheirwholeforcehavingbeenemployed;onthecontrary,theyseemtohaveturnedtocultivationoftheChersoneseandtopiracyfromwantofsupplies。ThiswaswhatreallyenabledtheTrojanstokeepthefieldfortenyearsagainstthem;thedispersionoftheenemymakingthemalwaysamatchforthedetachmentleftbehind。Iftheyhadbroughtplentyofsupplieswiththem,andhadperseveredinthewarwithoutscatteringforpiracyandagriculture,theywouldhaveeasilydefeatedtheTrojansinthefield,sincetheycouldholdtheirownagainstthemwiththedivisiononservice。Inshort,iftheyhadstucktothesiege,thecaptureofTroywouldhavecostthemlesstimeandlesstrouble。Butaswantofmoneyprovedtheweaknessofearlierexpeditions,sofromthesamecauseeventheoneinquestion,morefamousthanitspredecessors,maybepronouncedontheevidenceofwhatiteffectedtohavebeeninferiortoitsrenownandtothecurrentopinionaboutitformedunderthetuitionofthepoets。
EvenaftertheTrojanWar,Hellaswasstillengagedinremovingandsettling,andthuscouldnotattaintothequietwhichmustprecedegrowth。ThelatereturnoftheHellenesfromIliumcausedmanyrevolutions,andfactionsensuedalmosteverywhere;anditwasthecitizensthusdrivenintoexilewhofoundedthecities。SixtyyearsafterthecaptureofIlium,themodernBoeotiansweredrivenoutofArnebytheThessalians,andsettledinthepresentBoeotia,theformerCadmeis;thoughtherewasadivisionofthemtherebefore,someofwhomjoinedtheexpeditiontoIlium。Twentyyearslater,theDoriansandtheHeraclidsbecamemastersofPeloponnese;sothatmuchhadtobedoneandmanyyearshadtoelapsebeforeHellascouldattaintoadurabletranquillityundisturbedbyremovals,andcouldbegintosendoutcolonies,asAthensdidtoIoniaandmostoftheislands,andthePeloponnesianstomostofItalyandSicilyandsomeplacesintherestofHellas。AlltheseplaceswerefoundedsubsequentlytothewarwithTroy。
ButasthepowerofHellasgrew,andtheacquisitionofwealthbecamemoreanobject,therevenuesofthestatesincreasing,tyrannieswerebytheirmeansestablishedalmosteverywhere-theoldformofgovernmentbeinghereditarymonarchywithdefiniteprerogatives-andHellasbegantofitoutfleetsandapplyherselfmorecloselytothesea。ItissaidthattheCorinthianswerethefirsttoapproachthemodernstyleofnavalarchitecture,andthatCorinthwasthefirstplaceinHellaswheregalleyswerebuilt;andwehaveAmeinocles,aCorinthianshipwright,makingfourshipsfortheSamians。Datingfromtheendofthiswar,itisnearlythreehundredyearsagothatAmeinocleswenttoSamos。Again,theearliestsea-fightinhistorywasbetweentheCorinthiansandCorcyraeans;thiswasabouttwohundredandsixtyyearsago,datingfromthesametime。
Plantedonanisthmus,Corinthhadfromtimeoutofmindbeenacommercialemporium;asformerlyalmostallcommunicationbetweentheHelleneswithinandwithoutPeloponnesewascarriedonoverland,andtheCorinthianterritorywasthehighwaythroughwhichittravelled。
Shehadconsequentlygreatmoneyresources,asisshownbytheepithet"wealthy"bestowedbytheoldpoetsontheplace,andthisenabledher,whentrafficbyseabecamemorecommon,toprocurehernavyandputdownpiracy;andasshecouldofferamartforbothbranchesofthetrade,sheacquiredforherselfallthepowerwhichalargerevenueaffords。SubsequentlytheIoniansattainedtogreatnavalstrengthinthereignofCyrus,thefirstkingofthePersians,andofhissonCambyses,andwhiletheywereatwarwiththeformercommandedforawhiletheIoniansea。Polycratesalso,thetyrantofSamos,hadapowerfulnavyinthereignofCambyses,withwhichhereducedmanyoftheislands,andamongthemRhenea,whichheconsecratedtotheDelianApollo。AboutthistimealsothePhocaeans,whiletheywerefoundingMarseilles,defeatedtheCarthaginiansinasea-fight。
Thesewerethemostpowerfulnavies。Andeventhese,althoughsomanygenerationshadelapsedsincetheTrojanwar,seemtohavebeenprincipallycomposedoftheoldfifty-oarsandlong-boats,andtohavecountedfewgalleysamongtheirranks。IndeeditwasonlyshortlythePersianwar,andthedeathofDariusthesuccessorofCambyses,thattheSiciliantyrantsandtheCorcyraeansacquiredanylargenumberofgalleys。ForafterthesetherewerenonaviesofanyaccountinHellastilltheexpeditionofXerxes;Aegina,Athens,andothersmayhavepossessedafewvessels,buttheywereprincipallyfifty-oars。ItwasquiteattheendofthisperiodthatthewarwithAeginaandtheprospectofthebarbarianinvasionenabledThemistoclestopersuadetheAthenianstobuildthefleetwithwhichtheyfoughtatSalamis;andeventhesevesselshadnotcompletedecks。
Thenavies,then,oftheHellenesduringtheperiodwehavetraversedwerewhatIhavedescribed。Alltheirinsignificancedidnotpreventtheirbeinganelementofthegreatestpowertothosewhocultivatedthem,alikeinrevenueandindominion。Theywerethemeansbywhichtheislandswerereachedandreduced,thoseofthesmallestareafallingtheeasiestprey。Warsbylandtherewerenone,noneatleastbywhichpowerwasacquired;wehavetheusualbordercontests,butofdistantexpeditionswithconquestforobjectwehearnothingamongtheHellenes。Therewasnounionofsubjectcitiesroundagreatstate,nospontaneouscombinationofequalsforconfederateexpeditions;whatfightingtherewasconsistedmerelyoflocalwarfarebetweenrivalneighbours。ThenearestapproachtoacoalitiontookplaceintheoldwarbetweenChalcisandEretria;
thiswasaquarrelinwhichtherestoftheHellenicnamedidtosomeextenttakesides。
Various,too,weretheobstacleswhichthenationalgrowthencounteredinvariouslocalities。ThepoweroftheIonianswasadvancingwithrapidstrides,whenitcameintocollisionwithPersia,underKingCyrus,who,afterhavingdethronedCroesusandoverruneverythingbetweentheHalysandthesea,stoppednottillhehadreducedthecitiesofthecoast;theislandsbeingonlylefttobesubduedbyDariusandthePhoeniciannavy。
Again,whereverthereweretyrants,theirhabitofprovidingsimplyforthemselves,oflookingsolelytotheirpersonalcomfortandfamilyaggrandizement,madesafetythegreataimoftheirpolicy,andpreventedanythinggreatproceedingfromthem;thoughtheywouldeachhavetheiraffairswiththeirimmediateneighbours。Allthisisonlytrueofthemothercountry,forinSicilytheyattainedtoverygreatpower。ThusforalongtimeeverywhereinHellasdowefindcauseswhichmakethestatesalikeincapableofcombinationforgreatandnationalends,orofanyvigorousactionoftheirown。
ButatlastatimecamewhenthetyrantsofAthensandthefaroldertyranniesoftherestofHellaswere,withtheexceptionofthoseinSicily,onceandforallputdownbyLacedaemon;forthiscity,thoughafterthesettlementoftheDorians,itspresentinhabitants,itsufferedfromfactionsforanunparalleledlengthoftime,stillataveryearlyperiodobtainedgoodlaws,andenjoyedafreedomfromtyrantswhichwasunbroken;ithaspossessedthesameformofgovernmentformorethanfourhundredyears,reckoningtotheendofthelatewar,andhasthusbeeninapositiontoarrangetheaffairsoftheotherstates。Notmanyyearsafterthedepositionofthetyrants,thebattleofMarathonwasfoughtbetweentheMedesandtheAthenians。Tenyearsafterwards,thebarbarianreturnedwiththearmadaforthesubjugationofHellas。Inthefaceofthisgreatdanger,thecommandoftheconfederateHelleneswasassumedbytheLacedaemoniansinvirtueoftheirsuperiorpower;andtheAthenians,havingmadeuptheirmindstoabandontheircity,brokeuptheirhomes,threwthemselvesintotheirships,andbecameanavalpeople。
Thiscoalition,afterrepulsingthebarbarian,soonafterwardssplitintotwosections,whichincludedtheHelleneswhohadrevoltedfromtheKing,aswellasthosewhohadaidedhiminthewar。AttheendoftheonestoodAthens,attheheadoftheotherLacedaemon,onethefirstnaval,theotherthefirstmilitarypowerinHellas。Forashorttimetheleagueheldtogether,tilltheLacedaemoniansandAtheniansquarrelledandmadewaruponeachotherwiththeirallies,aduelintowhichalltheHellenessoonerorlaterweredrawn,thoughsomemightatfirstremainneutral。SothatthewholeperiodfromtheMedianwartothis,withsomepeacefulintervals,wasspentbyeachpowerinwar,eitherwithitsrival,orwithitsownrevoltedallies,andconsequentlyaffordedthemconstantpracticeinmilitarymatters,andthatexperiencewhichislearntintheschoolofdanger。
ThepolicyofLacedaemonwasnottoexacttributefromherallies,butmerelytosecuretheirsubserviencetoherinterestsbyestablishingoligarchiesamongthem;Athens,onthecontrary,hadbydegreesdeprivedhersoftheirships,andimposedinsteadcontributionsinmoneyonallexceptChiosandLesbos。Bothfoundtheirresourcesforthiswarseparatelytoexceedthesumoftheirstrengthwhentheallianceflourishedintact。
Havingnowgiventheresultofmyinquiriesintoearlytimes,I
grantthattherewillbeadifficultyinbelievingeveryparticulardetail。Thewaythatmostmendealwithtraditions,eventraditionsoftheirowncountry,istoreceivethemallalikeastheyaredelivered,withoutapplyinganycriticaltestwhatever。ThegeneralAthenianpublicfancythatHipparchuswastyrantwhenhefellbythehandsofHarmodiusandAristogiton,notknowingthatHippias,theeldestofthesonsofPisistratus,wasreallysupreme,andthatHipparchusandThessaluswerehisbrothers;andthatHarmodiusandAristogitonsuspecting,ontheveryday,nayattheverymomentfixedonforthedeed,thatinformationhadbeenconveyedtoHippiasbytheiraccomplices,concludedthathehadbeenwarned,anddidnotattackhim,yet,notlikingtobeapprehendedandrisktheirlivesfornothing,felluponHipparchusnearthetempleofthedaughtersofLeos,andslewhimashewasarrangingthePanathenaicprocession。
TherearemanyotherunfoundedideascurrentamongtherestoftheHellenes,evenonmattersofcontemporaryhistory,whichhavenotbeenobscuredbytime。Forinstance,thereisthenotionthattheLacedaemoniankingshavetwovoteseach,thefactbeingthattheyhaveonlyone;andthatthereisacompanyofPitane,therebeingsimplynosuchthing。Solittlepainsdothevulgartakeintheinvestigationoftruth,acceptingreadilythefirststorythatcomestohand。Onthewhole,however,theconclusionsIhavedrawnfromtheproofsquotedmay,Ibelieve,safelybereliedon。Assuredlytheywillnotbedisturbedeitherbythelaysofapoetdisplayingtheexaggerationofhiscraft,orbythecompositionsofthechroniclersthatareattractiveattruth'sexpense;thesubjectstheytreatofbeingoutofthereachofevidence,andtimehavingrobbedmostofthemofhistoricalvaluebyenthroningthemintheregionoflegend。Turningfromthese,wecanrestsatisfiedwithhavingproceededupontheclearestdata,andhavingarrivedatconclusionsasexactascanbeexpectedinmattersofsuchantiquity。Tocometothiswar:despitetheknowndispositionoftheactorsinastruggletooverrateitsimportance,andwhenitisovertoreturntotheiradmirationofearlierevents,yetanexaminationofthefactswillshowthatitwasmuchgreaterthanthewarswhichprecededit。
Withreferencetothespeechesinthishistory,someweredeliveredbeforethewarbegan,otherswhileitwasgoingon;someI
heardmyself,othersIgotfromvariousquarters;itwasinallcasesdifficulttocarrythemwordforwordinone'smemory,somyhabithasbeentomakethespeakerssaywhatwasinmyopiniondemandedofthembythevariousoccasions,ofcourseadheringascloselyaspossibletothegeneralsenseofwhattheyreallysaid。Andwithreferencetothenarrativeofevents,farfrompermittingmyselftoderiveitfromthefirstsourcethatcametohand,Ididnoteventrustmyownimpressions,butitrestspartlyonwhatIsawmyself,partlyonwhatotherssawforme,theaccuracyofthereportbeingalwaystriedbythemostsevereanddetailedtestspossible。
Myconclusionshavecostmesomelabourfromthewantofcoincidencebetweenaccountsofthesameoccurrencesbydifferenteye-witnesses,arisingsometimesfromimperfectmemory,sometimesfromunduepartialityforonesideortheother。Theabsenceofromanceinmyhistorywill,Ifear,detractsomewhatfromitsinterest;butifitbejudgedusefulbythoseinquirerswhodesireanexactknowledgeofthepastasanaidtotheinterpretationofthefuture,whichinthecourseofhumanthingsmustresembleifitdoesnotreflectit,I
shallbecontent。Infine,Ihavewrittenmywork,notasanessaywhichistowintheapplauseofthemoment,butasapossessionforalltime。
TheMedianWar,thegreatestachievementofpasttimes,yetfoundaspeedydecisionintwoactionsbyseaandtwobyland。ThePeloponnesianWarwasprolongedtoanimmenselength,and,longasitwas,itwasshortwithoutparallelforthemisfortunesthatitbroughtuponHellas。Neverhadsomanycitiesbeentakenandlaiddesolate,herebythebarbarians,herebythepartiescontending(theoldinhabitantsbeingsometimesremovedtomakeroomforothers);
neverwastheresomuchbanishingandblood-shedding,nowonthefieldofbattle,nowinthestrifeoffaction。Oldstoriesofoccurrenceshandeddownbytradition,butscantilyconfirmedbyexperience,suddenlyceasedtobeincredible;therewereearthquakesofunparalleledextentandviolence;eclipsesofthesunoccurredwithafrequencyunrecordedinprevioushistory;thereweregreatdroughtsinsundryplacesandconsequentfamines,andthatmostcalamitousandawfullyfatalvisitation,theplague。Allthiscameuponthemwiththelatewar,whichwasbegunbytheAtheniansandPeloponnesiansbythedissolutionofthethirtyyears'trucemadeaftertheconquestofEuboea。Tothequestionwhytheybrokethetreaty,Ianswerbyplacingfirstanaccountoftheirgroundsofcomplaintandpointsofdifference,thatnoonemayeverhavetoasktheimmediatecausewhichplungedtheHellenesintoawarofsuchmagnitude。TherealcauseIconsidertobetheonewhichwasformallymostkeptoutofsight。ThegrowthofthepowerofAthens,andthealarmwhichthisinspiredinLacedaemon,madewarinevitable。Stillitiswelltogivethegroundsallegedbyeithersidewhichledtothedissolutionofthetreatyandthebreakingoutofthewar。
CHAPTERII。
CausesoftheWar-TheAffairofEpidamnus-
TheAffairofPotidaeaTHEcityofEpidamnusstandsontherightoftheentranceoftheIonicGulf。ItsvicinityisinhabitedbytheTaulantians,anIllyrianpeople。TheplaceisacolonyfromCorcyra,foundedbyPhalius,sonofEratocleides,ofthefamilyoftheHeraclids,whohadaccordingtoancientusagebeensummonedforthepurposefromCorinth,themothercountry。ThecolonistswerejoinedbysomeCorinthians,andothersoftheDorianrace。Now,astimewenton,thecityofEpidamnusbecamegreatandpopulous;butfallingapreytofactionsarising,itissaid,fromawarwithherneighboursthebarbarians,shebecamemuchenfeebled,andlostaconsiderableamountofherpower。Thelastactbeforethewarwastheexpulsionofthenoblesbythepeople。Theexiledpartyjoinedthebarbarians,andproceededtoplunderthoseinthecitybyseaandland;andtheEpidamnians,findingthemselveshardpressed,sentambassadorstoCorcyrabeseechingtheirmothercountrynottoallowthemtoperish,buttomakeupmattersbetweenthemandtheexiles,andtoridthemofthewarwiththebarbarians。TheambassadorsseatedthemselvesinthetempleofHeraassuppliants,andmadetheaboverequeststotheCorcyraeans。ButtheCorcyraeansrefusedtoaccepttheirsupplication,andtheyweredismissedwithouthavingeffectedanything。
WhentheEpidamniansfoundthatnohelpcouldbeexpectedfromCorcyra,theywereinastraitwhattodonext。SotheysenttoDelphiandinquiredoftheGodwhethertheyshoulddelivertheircitytotheCorinthiansandendeavourtoobtainsomeassistancefromtheirfounders。TheanswerhegavethemwastodeliverthecityandplacethemselvesunderCorinthianprotection。SotheEpidamnianswenttoCorinthanddeliveredoverthecolonyinobediencetothecommandsoftheoracle。TheyshowedthattheirfoundercamefromCorinth,andrevealedtheanswerofthegod;andtheybeggedthemnottoallowthemtoperish,buttoassistthem。ThistheCorinthiansconsentedtodo。
BelievingthecolonytobelongasmuchtothemselvesastotheCorcyraeans,theyfeltittobeakindofdutytoundertaketheirprotection。Besides,theyhatedtheCorcyraeansfortheircontemptofthemothercountry。Insteadofmeetingwiththeusualhonoursaccordedtotheparentcitybyeveryothercolonyatpublicassemblies,suchasprecedenceatsacrifices,CorinthfoundherselftreatedwithcontemptbyapowerwhichinpointofwealthcouldstandcomparisonwithanyevenoftherichestcommunitiesinHellas,whichpossessedgreatmilitarystrength,andwhichsometimescouldnotrepressaprideinthehighnavalpositionofan,islandwhosenauticalrenowndatedfromthedaysofitsoldinhabitants,thePhaeacians。Thiswasonereasonofthecarethattheylavishedontheirfleet,whichbecameveryefficient;indeedtheybeganthewarwithaforceofahundredandtwentygalleys。
AllthesegrievancesmadeCorintheagertosendthepromisedaidtoEpidamnus。Advertisementwasmadeforvolunteersettlers,andaforceofAmbraciots,Leucadians,andCorinthianswasdispatched。
TheymarchedbylandtoApollonia,aCorinthiancolony,theroutebyseabeingavoidedfromfearofCorcyraeaninterruption。WhentheCorcyraeansheardofthearrivalofthesettlersandtroopsinEpidamnus,andthesurrenderofthecolonytoCorinth,theytookfire。
Instantlyputtingtoseawithfive-and-twentyships,whichwerequicklyfollowedbyothers,theyinsolentlycommandedtheEpidamnianstoreceivebackthebanishednobles-(itmustbepremisedthattheEpidamnianexileshadcometoCorcyraand,pointingtothesepulchresoftheirancestors,hadappealedtotheirkindredtorestorethem)-andtodismisstheCorinthiangarrisonandsettlers。
ButtoallthistheEpidamniansturnedadeafear。UponthistheCorcyraeanscommencedoperationsagainstthemwithafleetoffortysail。Theytookwiththemtheexiles,withaviewtotheirrestoration,andalsosecuredtheservicesoftheIllyrians。Sittingdownbeforethecity,theyissuedaproclamationtotheeffectthatanyofthenativesthatchose,andtheforeigners,mightdepartunharmed,withthealternativeofbeingtreatedasenemies。OntheirrefusaltheCorcyraeansproceededtobesiegethecity,whichstandsonanisthmus;andtheCorinthians,receivingintelligenceoftheinvestmentofEpidamnus,gottogetheranarmamentandproclaimedacolonytoEpidamnus,perfectpoliticalequalitybeingguaranteedtoallwhochosetogo。Anywhowerenotpreparedtosailatoncemight,bypayingdownthesumoffiftyCorinthiandrachmae,haveashareinthecolonywithoutleavingCorinth。Greatnumberstookadvantageofthisproclamation,somebeingreadytostartdirectly,otherspayingtherequisiteforfeit。IncaseoftheirpassagebeingdisputedbytheCorcyraeans,severalcitieswereaskedtolendthemaconvoy。Megarapreparedtoaccompanythemwitheightships,PaleinCephalloniawithfour;Epidaurusfurnishedfive,Hermioneone,Troezentwo,Leucasten,andAmbraciaeight。TheThebansandPhliasianswereaskedformoney,theEleansforhullsaswell;whileCorinthherselffurnishedthirtyshipsandthreethousandheavyinfantry。
WhentheCorcyraeansheardoftheirpreparationstheycametoCorinthwithenvoysfromLacedaemonandSicyon,whomtheypersuadedtoaccompanythem,andbadeherrecallthegarrisonandsettlers,asshehadnothingtodowithEpidamnus。If,however,shehadanyclaimstomake,theywerewillingtosubmitthemattertothearbitrationofsuchofthecitiesinPeloponneseasshouldbechosenbymutualagreement,andthatthecolonyshouldremainwiththecitytowhomthearbitratorsmightassignit。TheywerealsowillingtoreferthemattertotheoracleatDelphi。If,indefianceoftheirprotestations,warwasappealedto,theyshouldbethemselvescompelledbythisviolencetoseekfriendsinquarterswheretheyhadnodesiretoseekthem,andtomakeevenoldtiesgivewaytothenecessityofassistance。TheanswertheygotfromCorinthwasthat,iftheywouldwithdrawtheirfleetandthebarbariansfromEpidamnus,negotiationmightbepossible;but,whilethetownwasstillbeingbesieged,goingbeforearbitratorswasoutofthequestion。TheCorcyraeansretortedthatifCorinthwouldwithdrawhertroopsfromEpidamnustheywouldwithdrawtheirs,ortheywerereadytoletbothpartiesremaininstatuquo,anarmisticebeingconcludedtilljudgmentcouldbegiven。
Turningadeafeartoalltheseproposals,whentheirshipsweremannedandtheirallieshadcomein,theCorinthianssentaheraldbeforethemtodeclarewarand,gettingunderwaywithseventy-fiveshipsandtwothousandheavyinfantry,sailedforEpidamnustogivebattletotheCorcyraeans。ThefleetwasunderthecommandofAristeus,sonofPellichas,Callicrates,sonofCallias,andTimanor,sonofTimanthes;thetroopsunderthatofArchetimus,sonofEurytimus,andIsarchidas,sonofIsarchus。WhentheyhadreachedActiumintheterritoryofAnactorium,atthemouthofthemouthoftheGulfofAmbracia,wherethetempleofApollostands,theCorcyraeanssentonaheraldinalightboattowarnthemnottosailagainstthem。Meanwhiletheyproceededtomantheirships,allofwhichhadbeenequippedforaction,theoldvesselsbeingundergirdedtomakethemseaworthy。OnthereturnoftheheraldwithoutanypeacefulanswerfromtheCorinthians,theirshipsbeingnowmanned,theyputouttoseatomeettheenemywithafleetofeightysail(fortywereengagedinthesiegeofEpidamnus),formedline,andwentintoaction,andgainedadecisivevictory,anddestroyedfifteenoftheCorinthianvessels。ThesamedayhadseenEpidamnuscompelledbyitsbesiegerstocapitulate;theconditionsbeingthattheforeignersshouldbesold,andtheCorinthianskeptasprisonersofwar,tilltheirfateshouldbeotherwisedecided。
AftertheengagementtheCorcyraeanssetupatrophyonLeukimme,aheadlandofCorcyra,andslewalltheircaptivesexcepttheCorinthians,whomtheykeptasprisonersofwar。Defeatedatsea,theCorinthiansandtheiralliesrepairedhome,andlefttheCorcyraeansmastersofalltheseaaboutthoseparts。SailingtoLeucas,aCorinthiancolony,theyravagedtheirterritory,andburntCyllene,theharbouroftheEleans,becausetheyhadfurnishedshipsandmoneytoCorinth。Foralmostthewholeoftheperiodthatfollowedthebattletheyremainedmastersofthesea,andthealliesofCorinthwereharassedbyCorcyraeancruisers。AtlastCorinth,rousedbythesufferingsofherallies,sentoutshipsandtroopsinthefallofthesummer,whoformedanencampmentatActiumandaboutChimerium,inThesprotis,fortheprotectionofLeucasandtherestofthefriendlycities。TheCorcyraeansontheirpartformedasimilarstationonLeukimme。Neitherpartymadeanymovement,buttheyremainedconfrontingeachothertilltheendofthesummer,andwinterwasathandbeforeeitherofthemreturnedhome。
Corinth,exasperatedbythewarwiththeCorcyraeans,spentthewholeoftheyearaftertheengagementandthatsucceedingitinbuildingships,andinstrainingeverynervetoformanefficientfleet;rowersbeingdrawnfromPeloponneseandtherestofHellasbytheinducementoflargebounties。TheCorcyraeans,alarmedatthenewsoftheirpreparations,beingwithoutasingleallyinHellas(fortheyhadnotenrolledthemselveseitherintheAthenianorintheLacedaemonianconfederacy),decidedtorepairtoAthensinordertoenterintoallianceandtoendeavourtoprocuresupportfromher。
Corinthalso,hearingoftheirintentions,sentanembassytoAthenstopreventtheCorcyraeannavybeingjoinedbytheAthenian,andherprospectoforderingthewaraccordingtoherwishesbeingthusimpeded。Anassemblywasconvoked,andtherivaladvocatesappeared:
theCorcyraeansspokeasfollows:
"Athenians!whenapeoplethathavenotrenderedanyimportantserviceorsupporttotheirneighboursintimespast,forwhichtheymightclaimtoberepaid,appearbeforethemaswenowappearbeforeyoutosolicittheirassistance,theymayfairlyberequiredtosatisfycertainpreliminaryconditions。Theyshouldshow,first,thatitisexpedientoratleastsafetogranttheirrequest;next,thattheywillretainalastingsenseofthekindness。Butiftheycannotclearlyestablishanyofthesepoints,theymustnotbeannoyediftheymeetwitharebuff。NowtheCorcyraeansbelievethatwiththeirpetitionforassistancetheycanalsogiveyouasatisfactoryansweronthesepoints,andtheyhavethereforedispatchedushither。Ithassohappenedthatourpolicyasregardsyouwithrespecttothisrequest,turnsouttobeinconsistent,andasregardsourinterests,tobeatthepresentcrisisinexpedient。Wesayinconsistent,becauseapowerwhichhasneverinthewholeofherpasthistorybeenwillingtoallyherselfwithanyofherneighbours,isnowfoundaskingthemtoallythemselveswithher。Andwesayinexpedient,becauseinourpresentwarwithCorinthithasleftusinapositionofentireisolation,andwhatonceseemedthewiseprecautionofrefusingtoinvolveourselvesinallianceswithotherpowers,lestweshouldalsoinvolveourselvesinrisksoftheirchoosing,hasnowprovedtobefollyandweakness。ItistruethatinthelatenavalengagementwedrovebacktheCorinthiansfromourshoressingle-handed。ButtheyhavenowgottogetherastilllargerarmamentfromPeloponneseandtherestofHellas;andwe,seeingourutterinabilitytocopewiththemwithoutforeignaid,andthemagnitudeofthedangerwhichsubjectiontothemimplies,finditnecessarytoaskhelpfromyouandfromeveryotherpower。Andwehopetobeexcusedifweforswearouroldprincipleofcompletepoliticalisolation,aprinciplewhichwasnotadoptedwithanysinisterintention,butwasrathertheconsequenceofanerrorinjudgment。
"Nowtherearemanyreasonswhyintheeventofyourcomplianceyouwillcongratulateyourselvesonthisrequesthavingbeenmadetoyou。First,becauseyourassistancewillberenderedtoapowerwhich,herselfinoffensive,isavictimtotheinjusticeofothers。Secondly,becauseallthatwemostvalueisatstakeinthepresentcontest,andyourwelcomeofusunderthesecircumstanceswillbeaproofofgoodwillwhichwilleverkeepalivethegratitudeyouwilllayupinourhearts。Thirdly,yourselvesexcepted,wearethegreatestnavalpowerinHellas。Moreover,canyouconceiveastrokeofgoodfortunemorerareinitself,ormoredishearteningtoyourenemies,thanthatthepowerwhoseadhesionyouwouldhavevaluedabovemuchmaterialandmoralstrengthshouldpresentherselfself-invited,shoulddeliverherselfintoyourhandswithoutdangerandwithoutexpense,andshouldlastlyputyouinthewayofgainingahighcharacterintheeyesoftheworld,thegratitudeofthosewhomyoushallassist,andagreataccessionofstrengthforyourselves?Youmaysearchallhistorywithoutfindingmanyinstancesofapeoplegainingalltheseadvantagesatonce,ormanyinstancesofapowerthatcomesinquestofassistancebeinginapositiontogivetothepeoplewhoseallianceshesolicitsasmuchsafetyandhonourasshewillreceive。Butitwillbeurgedthatitisonlyinthecaseofawarthatweshallbefounduseful。Tothisweanswerthatifanyofyouimaginethatthatwarisfaroff,heisgrievouslymistaken,andisblindtothefactthatLacedaemonregardsyouwithjealousyanddesireswar,andthatCorinthispowerfulthere-thesame,remember,thatisyourenemy,andisevennowtryingtosubdueusasapreliminarytoattackingyou。Andthisshedoestopreventourbecomingunitedbyacommonenmity,andherhavingusbothonherhands,andalsotoensuregettingthestartofyouinoneoftwoways,eitherbycripplingourpowerorbymakingitsstrengthherown。Nowitisourpolicytobebeforehandwithher-thatis,forCorcyratomakeanofferofallianceandforyoutoacceptit;infact,weoughttoformplansagainstherinsteadofwaitingtodefeattheplanssheformsagainstus。
"Ifsheassertsthatforyoutoreceiveacolonyofhersintoallianceisnotright,letherknowthateverycolonythatiswelltreatedhonoursitsparentstate,butbecomesestrangedfromitbyinjustice。Forcolonistsarenotsentforthontheunderstandingthattheyaretobetheslavesofthosethatremainbehind,butthattheyaretobetheirequals。AndthatCorinthwasinjuringusisclear。InvitedtoreferthedisputeaboutEpidamnustoarbitration,theychosetoprosecutetheircomplaintswarratherthanbyafairtrial。Andlettheirconducttowardsuswhoaretheirkindredbeawarningtoyounottobemisledbytheirdeceit,nortoyieldtotheirdirectrequests;concessionstoadversariesonlyendinself-reproach,andthemorestrictlytheyareavoidedthegreaterwillbethechanceofsecurity。
"IfitbeurgedthatyourreceptionofuswillbeabreachofthetreatyexistingbetweenyouandLacedaemon,theansweristhatweareaneutralstate,andthatoneoftheexpressprovisionsofthattreatyisthatitshallbecompetentforanyHellenicstatethatisneutraltojoinwhicheversideitpleases。AnditisintolerableforCorinthtobeallowedtoobtainmenforhernavynotonlyfromherallies,butalsofromtherestofHellas,nosmallnumberbeingfurnishedbyyourownsubjects;whilewearetobeexcludedbothfromtheallianceleftopentousbytreaty,andfromanyassistancethatwemightgetfromotherquarters,andyouaretobeaccusedofpoliticalimmoralityifyoucomplywithourrequest。Ontheotherhand,weshallhavemuchgreatercausetocomplainofyou,ifyoudonotcomplywithit;ifwe,whoareinperilandarenoenemiesofyours,meetwitharepulseatyourhands,whileCorinth,whoistheaggressorandyourenemy,notonlymeetswithnohindrancefromyou,butisevenallowedtodrawmaterialforwarfromyourdependencies。
Thisoughtnottobe,butyoushouldeitherforbidherenlistingmeninyourdominions,oryoushouldlendustoowhathelpyoumaythinkadvisable。
"Butyourrealpolicyistoaffordusavowedcountenanceandsupport。Theadvantagesofthiscourse,aswepremisedinthebeginningofourspeech,aremany。Wementiononethatisperhapsthechief。Couldtherebeaclearerguaranteeofourgoodfaiththanisofferedbythefactthatthepowerwhichisatenmitywithyouisalsoatenmitywithus,andthatthatpowerisfullyabletopunishdefection?Andthereisawidedifferencebetweendecliningtheallianceofaninlandandofamaritimepower。Foryourfirstendeavourshouldbetoprevent,ifpossible,theexistenceofanynavalpowerexceptyourown;failingthis,tosecurethefriendshipofthestrongestthatdoesexist。Andifanyofyoubelievethatwhatweurgeisexpedient,butfeartoactuponthisbelief,lestitshouldleadtoabreachofthetreaty,youmustrememberthatontheonehand,whateveryourfears,yourstrengthwillbeformidabletoyourantagonists;ontheother,whatevertheconfidenceyouderivefromrefusingtoreceiveus,yourweaknesswillhavenoterrorsforastrongenemy。YoumustalsorememberthatyourdecisionisforAthensnolessthanCorcyra,andthatyouarenotmakingthebestprovisionforherinterests,ifatatimewhenyouareanxiouslyscanningthehorizonthatyoumaybeinreadinessforthebreakingoutofthewarwhichisallbutuponyou,youhesitatetoattachtoyoursideaplacewhoseadhesionorestrangementisalikepregnantwiththemostvitalconsequences。Foritliesconvenientlyforthecoast-
navigationinthedirectionofItalyandSicily,beingabletobarthepassageofnavalreinforcementsfromthencetoPeloponnese,andfromPeloponnesethither;anditisinotherrespectsamostdesirablestation。Tosumupasshortlyaspossible,embracingbothgeneralandparticularconsiderations,letthisshowyouthefollyofsacrificingus。RememberthattherearebutthreeconsiderablenavalpowersinHellas-Athens,Corcyra,andCorinth-andthatifyouallowtwoofthesethreetobecomeone,andCorinthtosecureusforherself,youwillhavetoholdtheseaagainsttheunitedfleetsofCorcyraandPeloponnese。Butifyoureceiveus,youwillhaveourshipstoreinforceyouinthestruggle。"
SuchwerethewordsoftheCorcyraeans。Aftertheyhadfinished,theCorinthiansspokeasfollows:
"TheseCorcyraeansinthespeechwehavejusthearddonotconfinethemselvestothequestionoftheirreceptionintoyouralliance。Theyalsotalkofourbeingguiltyofinjustice,andtheirbeingthevictimsofanunjustifiablewar。Itbecomesnecessaryforustotouchuponboththesepointsbeforeweproceedtotherestofwhatwehavetosay,thatyoumayhaveamorecorrectideaofthegroundsofourclaim,andhavegoodcausetorejecttheirpetition。
Accordingtothem,theiroldpolicyofrefusingalloffersofalliancewasapolicyofmoderation。Itwasinfactadoptedforbadends,notforgood;indeedtheirconductissuchastomakethembynomeansdesirousofhavingalliespresenttowitnessit,orofhavingtheshameofaskingtheirconcurrence。Besides,theirgeographicalsituationmakesthemindependentofothers,andconsequentlythedecisionincaseswheretheyinjureanyliesnotwithjudgesappointedbymutualagreement,butwiththemselves,because,whiletheyseldommakevoyagestotheirneighbours,theyareconstantlybeingvisitedbyforeignvesselswhicharecompelledtoputintoCorcyra。Inshort,theobjectthattheyproposetothemselves,intheirspeciouspolicyofcompleteisolation,isnottoavoidsharinginthecrimesofothers,buttosecuremonopolyofcrimetothemselves-thelicenceofoutragewherevertheycancompel,offraudwherevertheycanelude,andtheenjoymentoftheirgainswithoutshame。Andyetiftheywerethehonestmentheypretendtobe,thelessholdthatothershaduponthem,thestrongerwouldbethelightinwhichtheymighthaveputtheirhonestybygivingandtakingwhatwasjust。
"Butsuchhasnotbeentheirconducteithertowardsothersortowardsus。Theattitudeofourcolonytowardsushasalwaysbeenoneofestrangementandisnowoneofhostility;for,saythey:'Wewerenotsentouttobeill-treated。'Werejointhatwedidnotfoundthecolonytobeinsultedbythem,buttobetheirheadandtoberegardedwithaproperrespect。Atanyrateourothercolonieshonourus,andwearemuchbelovedbyourcolonists;andclearly,ifthemajorityaresatisfiedwithus,thesecanhavenogoodreasonforadissatisfactioninwhichtheystandalone,andwearenotactingimproperlyinmakingwaragainstthem,norarewemakingwaragainstthemwithouthavingreceivedsignalprovocation。Besides,ifwewereinthewrong,itwouldbehonourableinthemtogivewaytoourwishes,anddisgracefulforustotrampleontheirmoderation;butintheprideandlicenceofwealththeyhavesinnedagainandagainagainstus,andnevermoredeeplythanwhenEpidamnus,ourdependency,whichtheytooknostepstoclaiminitsdistressuponourcomingtorelieveit,wasbythemseized,andisnowheldbyforceofarms。
"Astotheirallegationthattheywishedthequestiontobefirstsubmittedtoarbitration,itisobviousthatachallengecomingfromthepartywhoissafeinacommandingpositioncannotgainthecreditdueonlytohimwho,beforeappealingtoarms,indeedsaswellaswords,placeshimselfonalevelwithhisadversary。Intheircase,itwasnotbeforetheylaidsiegetotheplace,butaftertheyatlengthunderstoodthatweshouldnottamelysufferit,thattheythoughtofthespeciouswordarbitration。Andnotsatisfiedwiththeirownmisconductthere,theyappearherenowrequiringyoutojoinwiththemnotinalliancebutincrime,andtoreceivetheminspiteoftheirbeingatenmitywithus。Butitwaswhentheystoodfirmestthattheyshouldhavemadeoverturestoyou,andnotatatimewhenwehavebeenwrongedandtheyareinperil;noryetatatimewhenyouwillbeadmittingtoashareinyourprotectionthosewhoneveradmittedyoutoashareintheirpower,andwillbeincurringanequalamountofblamefromuswiththoseinwhoseoffencesyouhadnohand。No,theyshouldhavesharedtheirpowerwithyoubeforetheyaskedyoutoshareyourfortuneswiththem。
"Sothentherealityofthegrievanceswecometocomplainof,andtheviolenceandrapacityofouropponents,havebothbeenproved。Butthatyoucannotequitablyreceivethem,thisyouhavestilltolearn。Itmaybetruethatoneoftheprovisionsofthetreatyisthatitshallbecompetentforanystate,whosenamewasnotdownonthelist,tojoinwhicheversideitpleases。Butthisagreementisnotmeantforthosewhoseobjectinjoiningistheinjuryofotherpowers,butforthosewhoseneedofsupportdoesnotarisefromthefactofdefection,andwhoseadhesionwillnotbringtothepowerthatismadenoughtoreceivethemwarinsteadofpeace;whichwillbethecasewithyou,ifyourefusetolistentous。Foryoucannotbecometheirauxiliaryandremainourfriend;ifyoujoinintheirattack,youmustsharethepunishmentwhichthedefendersinflictonthem。Andyetyouhavethebestpossiblerighttobeneutral,or,failingthis,youshouldonthecontraryjoinusagainstthem。Corinthisatleastintreatywithyou;withCorcyrayouwereneverevenintruce。
Butdonotlaydowntheprinciplethatdefectionistobepatronized。DidweonthedefectionoftheSamiansrecordourvoteagainstyou,whentherestofthePeloponnesianpowerswereequallydividedonthequestionwhethertheyshouldassistthem?No,wetoldthemtotheirfacethateverypowerhasarighttopunishitsownallies。Why,ifyoumakeityourpolicytoreceiveandassistalloffenders,youwillfindthatjustasmanyofyourdependencieswillcomeovertous,andtheprinciplethatyouestablishwillpresslessheavilyonusthanonyourselves。
"ThistheniswhatHelleniclawentitlesustodemandasaright。
Butwehavealsoadvicetoofferandclaimsonyourgratitude,which,sincethereisnodangerofourinjuringyou,aswearenotenemies,andsinceourfriendshipdoesnotamounttoveryfrequentintercourse,wesayoughttobeliquidatedatthepresentjuncture。
WhenyouwereinwantofshipsofwarforthewaragainsttheAeginetans,beforethePersianinvasion,Corinthsuppliedyouwithtwentyvessels。Thatgoodturn,andthelinewetookontheSamianquestion,whenwewerethecauseofthePeloponnesiansrefusingtoassistthem,enabledyoutoconquerAeginaandtopunishSamos。Andweactedthusatcriseswhen,ifever,menarewontintheireffortsagainsttheirenemiestoforgeteverythingforthesakeofvictory,regardinghimwhoassiststhemthenasafriend,evenifthusfarhehasbeenafoe,andhimwhoopposesthemthenasafoe,evenifhehasthusfarbeenafriend;indeedtheyallowtheirrealintereststosufferfromtheirabsorbingpreoccupationinthestruggle。
"Weighwelltheseconsiderations,andletyouryouthlearnwhattheyarefromtheirelders,andletthemdeterminetodountousaswehavedoneuntoyou。Andletthemnotacknowledgethejusticeofwhatwesay,butdisputeitswisdominthecontingencyofwar。Notonlyisthestraightestpathgenerallyspeakingthewisest;butthecomingofthewar,whichtheCorcyraeanshaveusedasabugbeartopersuadeyoutodowrong,isstilluncertain,anditisnotworthwhiletobecarriedawaybyitintogainingtheinstantanddeclaredenmityofCorinth。Itwere,rather,wisetotryandcounteracttheunfavourableimpressionwhichyourconducttoMegarahascreated。
Forkindnessopportunelyshownhasagreaterpowerofremovingoldgrievancesthanthefactsofthecasemaywarrant。Anddonotbeseducedbytheprospectofagreatnavalalliance。Abstinencefromallinjusticetootherfirst-ratepowersisagreatertowerofstrengththananythingthatcanbegainedbythesacrificeofpermanenttranquillityforanapparenttemporaryadvantage。ItisnowourturntobenefitbytheprinciplethatwelaiddownatLacedaemon,thateverypowerhasarighttopunishherownallies。Wenowclaimtoreceivethesamefromyou,andprotestagainstyourrewardingusforbenefitingyoubyourvotebyinjuringusbyyours。Onthecontrary,returnuslikeforlike,rememberingthatthisisthatverycrisisinwhichhewholendsaidismostafriend,andhewhoopposesismostafoe。AndfortheseCorcyraeans-neitherreceivethemintoallianceinourdespite,norbetheirabettorsincrime。Sodo,andyouwillactaswehavearighttoexpectofyou,andatthesametimebestconsultyourowninterests。"
SuchwerethewordsoftheCorinthians。
WhentheAthenianshadheardbothout,twoassemblieswereheld。
InthefirsttherewasamanifestdispositiontolistentotherepresentationsofCorinth;inthesecond,publicfeelinghadchangedandanalliancewithCorcyrawasdecidedon,withcertainreservations。Itwastobeadefensive,notanoffensivealliance。
ItdidnotinvolveabreachofthetreatywithPeloponnese:AthenscouldnotberequiredtojoinCorcyrainanyattackuponCorinth。
Buteachofthecontractingpartieshadarighttotheother'sassistanceagainstinvasion,whetherofhisownterritoryorthatofanally。ForitbegannowtobefeltthatthecomingofthePeloponnesianwarwasonlyaquestionoftime,andnoonewaswillingtoseeanavalpowerofsuchmagnitudeasCorcyrasacrificedtoCorinth;thoughiftheycouldletthemweakeneachotherbymutualconflict,itwouldbenobadpreparationforthestrugglewhichAthensmightonedayhavetowagewithCorinthandtheothernavalpowers。AtthesametimetheislandseemedtolieconvenientlyonthecoastingpassagetoItalyandSicily。Withtheseviews,AthensreceivedCorcyraintoallianceand,onthedepartureoftheCorinthiansnotlongafterwards,senttenshipstotheirassistance。
TheywerecommandedbyLacedaemonius,thesonofCimon,Diotimus,thesonofStrombichus,andProteas,thesonofEpicles。TheirinstructionsweretoavoidcollisionwiththeCorinthianfleetexceptundercertaincircumstances。IfitsailedtoCorcyraandthreatenedalandingonhercoast,orinanyofherpossessions,theyweretodotheirutmosttopreventit。Theseinstructionswerepromptedbyananxietytoavoidabreachofthetreaty。
MeanwhiletheCorinthianscompletedtheirpreparations,andsailedforCorcyrawithahundredandfiftyships。OftheseElisfurnishedten,Megaratwelve,Leucasten,Ambraciatwenty-seven,Anactoriumone,andCorinthherselfninety。Eachofthesecontingentshaditsownadmiral,theCorinthianbeingunderthecommandofXenoclides,sonofEuthycles,withfourcolleagues。SailingfromLeucas,theymadelandatthepartofthecontinentoppositeCorcyra。TheyanchoredintheharbourofChimerium,intheterritoryofThesprotis,abovewhich,atsomedistancefromthesea,liesthecityofEphyre,intheEleandistrict。BythiscitytheAcherusianlakepoursitswatersintothesea。ItgetsitsnamefromtheriverAcheron,whichflowsthroughThesprotisandfallsintothelake。TherealsotheriverThyamisflows,formingtheboundarybetweenThesprotisandKestrine;andbetweentheseriversrisesthepointofChimerium。InthispartofthecontinenttheCorinthiansnowcametoanchor,andformedanencampment。WhentheCorcyraeanssawthemcoming,theymannedahundredandtenships,commandedbyMeikiades,Aisimides,andEurybatus,andstationedthemselvesatoneoftheSybotaisles;thetenAthenianshipsbeingpresent。OnPointLeukimmetheypostedtheirlandforces,andathousandheavyinfantrywhohadcomefromZacynthustotheirassistance。NorweretheCorinthiansonthemainlandwithouttheirallies。Thebarbariansflockedinlargenumberstotheirassistance,theinhabitantsofthispartofthecontinentbeingoldalliesoftheirs。
WhentheCorinthianpreparationswerecompleted,theytookthreedays'provisionsandputoutfromChimeriumbynight,readyforaction。Sailingwiththedawn,theysightedtheCorcyraeanfleetoutatseaandcomingtowardsthem。Whentheyperceivedeachother,bothsidesformedinorderofbattle。OntheCorcyraeanrightwinglaytheAthenianships,therestofthelinebeingoccupiedbytheirownvesselsformedinthreesquadrons,eachofwhichwascommandedbyoneofthethreeadmirals。SuchwastheCorcyraeanformation。TheCorinthianwasasfollows:ontherightwinglaytheMegarianandAmbraciotships,inthecentretherestofthealliesinorder。ButtheleftwascomposedofthebestsailersintheCorinthiannavy,toencountertheAtheniansandtherightwingoftheCorcyraeans。Assoonasthesignalswereraisedoneitherside,theyjoinedbattle。Bothsideshadalargenumberofheavyinfantryontheirdecks,andalargenumberofarchersanddarters,theoldimperfectarmamentstillprevailing。Thesea-fightwasanobstinateone,thoughnotremarkableforitsscience;indeeditwasmorelikeabattlebyland。Whenevertheychargedeachother,themultitudeandcrushofthevesselsmadeitbynomeanseasytogetloose;besides,theirhopesofvictorylayprincipallyintheheavyinfantryonthedecks,whostoodandfoughtinorder,theshipsremainingstationary。Themanoeuvreofbreakingthelinewasnottried;inshort,strengthandpluckhadmoreshareinthefightthanscience。Everywheretumultreigned,thebattlebeingonesceneofconfusion;meanwhiletheAthenianships,bycominguptotheCorcyraeanswhenevertheywerepressed,servedtoalarmtheenemy,thoughtheircommanderscouldnotjoininthebattlefromfearoftheirinstructions。TherightwingoftheCorinthianssufferedmost。TheCorcyraeansroutedit,andchasedthemindisordertothecontinentwithtwentyships,saileduptotheircamp,andburntthetentswhichtheyfoundempty,andplunderedthestuff。SointhisquartertheCorinthiansandtheiralliesweredefeated,andtheCorcyraeanswerevictorious。ButwheretheCorinthiansthemselveswere,ontheleft,theygainedadecidedsuccess;thescantyforcesoftheCorcyraeansbeingfurtherweakenedbythewantofthetwentyshipsabsentonthepursuit。SeeingtheCorcyraeanshardpressed,theAtheniansbeganatlengthtoassistthemmoreunequivocally。Atfirst,itistrue,theyrefrainedfromcharginganyships;butwhentheroutwasbecomingpatent,andtheCorinthianswerepressingon,thetimeatlastcamewheneveryonesetto,andalldistinctionwaslaidaside,anditcametothispoint,thattheCorinthiansandAtheniansraisedtheirhandsagainsteachother。
Aftertherout,theCorinthians,insteadofemployingthemselvesinlashingfastandhaulingafterthemthehullsofthevesselswhichtheyhaddisabled,turnedtheirattentiontothemen,whomtheybutcheredastheysailedthrough,notcaringsomuchtomakeprisoners。Someevenoftheirownfriendswereslainbythem,bymistake,intheirignoranceofthedefeatoftherightwingForthenumberoftheshipsonbothsides,andthedistancetowhichtheycoveredthesea,madeitdifficult,aftertheyhadoncejoined,todistinguishbetweentheconqueringandtheconquered;thisbattleprovingfargreaterthananybeforeit,anyatleastbetweenHellenes,forthenumberofvesselsengaged。AftertheCorinthianshadchasedtheCorcyraeanstotheland,theyturnedtothewrecksandtheirdead,mostofwhomtheysucceededingettingholdofandconveyingtoSybota,therendezvousofthelandforcesfurnishedbytheirbarbarianallies。Sybota,itmustbeknown,isadesertharbourofThesprotis。
Thistaskover,theymusteredanew,andsailedagainsttheCorcyraeans,whoontheirpartadvancedtomeetthemwithalltheirshipsthatwerefitforserviceandremainingtothem,accompaniedbytheAthenianvessels,fearingthattheymightattemptalandingintheirterritory。Itwasbythistimegettinglate,andthepaeanhadbeensungfortheattack,whentheCorinthianssuddenlybegantobackwater。TheyhadobservedtwentyAthenianshipssailingup,whichhadbeensentoutafterwardstoreinforcethetenvesselsbytheAthenians,whofeared,asitturnedoutjustly,thedefeatoftheCorcyraeansandtheinabilityoftheirhandfulofshipstoprotectthem。TheseshipswerethusseenbytheCorinthiansfirst。TheysuspectedthattheywerefromAthens,andthatthosewhichtheysawwerenotall,butthatthereweremorebehind;theyaccordinglybegantoretire。TheCorcyraeansmeanwhilehadnotsightedthem,astheywereadvancingfromapointwhichtheycouldnotsowellsee,andwerewonderingwhytheCorinthianswerebackingwater,whensomecaughtsightofthem,andcriedoutthattherewereshipsinsightahead。Uponthistheyalsoretired;foritwasnowgettingdark,andtheretreatoftheCorinthianshadsuspendedhostilities。Thustheypartedfromeachother,andthebattleceasedwithnight。TheCorcyraeanswereintheircampatLeukimme,whenthesetwentyshipsfromAthens,underthecommandofGlaucon,thesonofLeagrus,andAndocides,sonofLeogoras,boreonthroughthecorpsesandthewrecks,andsaileduptothecamp,notlongaftertheyweresighted。
Itwasnownight,andtheCorcyraeansfearedthattheymightbehostilevessels;buttheysoonknewthem,andtheshipscametoanchor。
ThenextdaythethirtyAthenianvesselsputouttosea,accompaniedbyalltheCorcyraeanshipsthatwereseaworthy,andsailedtotheharbouratSybota,wheretheCorinthianslay,toseeiftheywouldengage。TheCorinthiansputoutfromthelandandformedalineintheopensea,butbeyondthismadenofurthermovement,havingnointentionofassumingtheoffensive。FortheysawreinforcementsarrivedfreshfromAthens,andthemselvesconfrontedbynumerousdifficulties,suchasthenecessityofguardingtheprisonerswhomtheyhadonboardandthewantofallmeansofrefittingtheirshipsinadesertplace。Whattheywerethinkingmoreaboutwashowtheirvoyagehomewastobeeffected;theyfearedthattheAtheniansmightconsiderthatthetreatywasdissolvedbythecollisionwhichhadoccurred,andforbidtheirdeparture。
Accordinglytheyresolvedtoputsomemenonboardaboat,andsendthemwithoutaherald'swandtotheAthenians,asanexperiment。Havingdoneso,theyspokeasfollows:"Youdowrong,Athenians,tobeginwarandbreakthetreaty。Engagedinchastisingourenemies,wefindyouplacingyourselvesinourpathinarmsagainstus。NowifyourintentionsaretopreventussailingtoCorcyra,oranywhereelsethatwemaywish,andifyouareforbreakingthetreaty,firsttakeusthatarehereandtreatusasenemies。"Suchwaswhattheysaid,andalltheCorcyraeanarmamentthatwerewithinhearingimmediatelycalledouttotakethemandkillthem。ButtheAtheniansansweredasfollows:"Neitherarewebeginningwar,Peloponnesians,norarewebreakingthetreaty;buttheseCorcyraeansareourallies,andwearecometohelpthem。Soifyouwanttosailanywhereelse,weplacenoobstacleinyourway;
butifyouaregoingtosailagainstCorcyra,oranyofherpossessions,weshalldoourbesttostopyou。"
ReceivingthisanswerfromtheAthenians,theCorinthianscommencedpreparationsfortheirvoyagehome,andsetupatrophyinSybota,onthecontinent;whiletheCorcyraeanstookupthewrecksanddeadthathadbeencarriedouttothembythecurrent,andbyawindwhichroseinthenightandscatteredtheminalldirections,andsetuptheirtrophyinSybota,ontheisland,asvictors。Thereasonseachsidehadforclaimingthevictorywerethese。TheCorinthianshadbeenvictoriousinthesea-fightuntilnight;andhavingthusbeenenabledtocarryoffmostwrecksanddead,theywereinpossessionofnofewerthanathousandprisonersofwar,andhadsunkcloseuponseventyvessels。TheCorcyraeanshaddestroyedaboutthirtyships,andafterthearrivaloftheAthenianshadtakenupthewrecksanddeadontheirside;theyhadbesidesseentheCorinthiansretirebeforethem,backingwateronsightoftheAthenianvessels,anduponthearrivaloftheAtheniansrefusetosailoutagainstthemfromSybota。Thusbothsidesclaimedthevictory。
TheCorinthiansonthevoyagehometookAnactorium,whichstandsatthemouthoftheAmbraciangulf。Theplacewastakenbytreachery,beingcommongroundtotheCorcyraeansandCorinthians。
AfterestablishingCorinthiansettlersthere,theyretiredhome。EighthundredoftheCorcyraeanswereslaves;thesetheysold;twohundredandfiftytheyretainedincaptivity,andtreatedwithgreatattention,inthehopethattheymightbringovertheircountrytoCorinthontheirreturn;mostofthembeing,asithappened,menofveryhighpositioninCorcyra。InthiswayCorcyramaintainedherpoliticalexistenceinthewarwithCorinth,andtheAthenianvesselslefttheisland。ThiswasthefirstcauseofthewarthatCorinthhadagainsttheAthenians,viz。,thattheyhadfoughtagainstthemwiththeCorcyraeansintimeoftreaty。
Almostimmediatelyafterthis,freshdifferencesarosebetweentheAtheniansandPeloponnesians,andcontributedtheirsharetothewar。Corinthwasformingschemesforretaliation,andAthenssuspectedherhostility。ThePotidaeans,whoinhabittheisthmusofPallene,beingaCorinthiancolony,buttributaryalliesofAthens,wereorderedtorazethewalllookingtowardsPallene,togivehostages,todismisstheCorinthianmagistrates,andinfuturenottoreceivethepersonssentfromCorinthannuallytosucceedthem。ItwasfearedthattheymightbepersuadedbyPerdiccasandtheCorinthianstorevolt,andmightdrawtherestofthealliesinthedirectionofThracetorevoltwiththem。TheseprecautionsagainstthePotidaeansweretakenbytheAtheniansimmediatelyafterthebattleatCorcyra。NotonlywasCorinthatlengthopenlyhostile,butPerdiccas,sonofAlexander,kingoftheMacedonians,hadfromanoldfriendandallybeenmadeanenemy。HehadbeenmadeanenemybytheAtheniansenteringintoalliancewithhisbrotherPhilipandDerdas,whowereinleagueagainsthim。InhisalarmhehadsenttoLacedaemontotryandinvolvetheAtheniansinawarwiththePeloponnesians,andwasendeavouringtowinoverCorinthinordertobringabouttherevoltofPotidaea。HealsomadeoverturestotheChalcidiansinthedirectionofThrace,andtotheBottiaeans,topersuadethemtojoinintherevolt;forhethoughtthatiftheseplacesonthebordercouldbemadehisallies,itwouldbeeasiertocarryonthewarwiththeirco-operation。Alivetoallthis,andwishingtoanticipatetherevoltofthecities,theAtheniansactedasfollows。TheywerejustthensendingoffthirtyshipsandathousandheavyinfantryforhiscountryunderthecommandofArchestratus,sonofLycomedes,withfourcolleagues。TheyinstructedthecaptainstotakehostagesofthePotidaeans,torazethewall,andtobeontheirguardagainsttherevoltoftheneighbouringcities。
MeanwhilethePotidaeanssentenvoystoAthensonthechanceofpersuadingthemtotakenonewstepsintheirmatters;theyalsowenttoLacedaemonwiththeCorinthianstosecuresupportincaseofneed。FailingafterprolongednegotiationtoobtainanythingsatisfactoryfromtheAthenians;beingunable,foralltheycouldsay,topreventthevesselsthatweredestinedforMacedoniafromalsosailingagainstthem;andreceivingfromtheLacedaemoniangovernmentapromisetoinvadeAttica,iftheAtheniansshouldattackPotidaea,thePotidaeans,thusfavouredbythemoment,atlastenteredintoleaguewiththeChalcidiansandBottiaeans,andrevolted。AndPerdiccasinducedtheChalcidianstoabandonanddemolishtheirtownsontheseaboardand,settlinginlandatOlynthus,tomakethatonecityastrongplace:meanwhiletothosewhofollowedhisadvicehegaveapartofhisterritoryinMygdoniaroundLakeBolbeasaplaceofabodewhilethewaragainsttheAtheniansshouldlast。Theyaccordinglydemolishedtheirtowns,removedinlandandpreparedforwar。ThethirtyshipsoftheAthenians,arrivingbeforetheThracianplaces,foundPotidaeaandtherestinrevolt。Theircommanders,consideringittobequiteimpossiblewiththeirpresentforcetocarryonwarwithPerdiccasandwiththeconfederatetownsaswellturnedtoMacedonia,theiroriginaldestination,and,havingestablishedthemselvesthere,carriedonwarinco-operationwithPhilip,andthebrothersofDerdas,whohadinvadedthecountryfromtheinterior。
MeanwhiletheCorinthians,withPotidaeainrevoltandtheAthenianshipsonthecoastofMacedonia,alarmedforthesafetyoftheplaceandthinkingitsdangertheirs,sentvolunteersfromCorinth,andmercenariesfromtherestofPeloponnese,tothenumberofsixteenhundredheavyinfantryinall,andfourhundredlighttroops。Aristeus,sonofAdimantus,whowasalwaysasteadyfriendtothePotidaeans,tookcommandoftheexpedition,anditwasprincipallyforloveofhimthatmostofthemenfromCorinthvolunteered。TheyarrivedinThracefortydaysaftertherevoltofPotidaea。
TheAtheniansalsoimmediatelyreceivedthenewsoftherevoltofthecities。OnbeinginformedthatAristeusandhisreinforcementswereontheirway,theysenttwothousandheavyinfantryoftheirowncitizensandfortyshipsagainsttheplacesinrevolt,underthecommandofCallias,sonofCalliades,andfourcolleagues。TheyarrivedinMacedoniafirst,andfoundtheforceofathousandmenthathadbeenfirstsentout,justbecomemastersofThermeandbesiegingPydna。Accordinglytheyalsojoinedintheinvestment,andbesiegedPydnaforawhile。SubsequentlytheycametotermsandconcludedaforcedalliancewithPerdiccas,hastenedbythecallsofPotidaeaandbythearrivalofAristeusatthatplace。TheywithdrewfromMacedonia,goingtoBeroeaandthencetoStrepsa,and,afterafutileattemptonthelatterplace,theypursuedbylandtheirmarchtoPotidaeawiththreethousandheavyinfantryoftheirowncitizens,besidesanumberoftheirallies,andsixhundredMacedonianhorsemen,thefollowersofPhilipandPausanias。Withthesesailedseventyshipsalongthecoast。Advancingbyshortmarches,onthethirddaytheyarrivedatGigonus,wheretheyencamped。
MeanwhilethePotidaeansandthePeloponnesianswithAristeuswereencampedonthesidelookingtowardsOlynthusontheisthmus,inexpectationoftheAthenians,andhadestablishedtheirmarketoutsidethecity。TheallieshadchosenAristeusgeneralofalltheinfantry;whilethecommandofthecavalrywasgiventoPerdiccas,whohadatoncelefttheallianceoftheAtheniansandgonebacktothatofthePotidaeans,havingdeputedIolausashisgeneral:TheplanofAristeuswastokeephisownforceontheisthmus,andawaittheattackoftheAthenians;leavingtheChalcidiansandthealliesoutsidetheisthmus,andthetwohundredcavalryfromPerdiccasinOlynthustoactupontheAthenianrear,ontheoccasionoftheiradvancingagainsthim;andthustoplacetheenemybetweentwofires。WhileCalliastheAtheniangeneralandhiscolleaguesdispatchedtheMacedonianhorseandafewofthealliestoOlynthus,topreventanymovementbeingmadefromthatquarter,theAtheniansthemselvesbrokeuptheircampandmarchedagainstPotidaea。Aftertheyhadarrivedattheisthmus,andsawtheenemypreparingforbattle,theyformedagainsthim,andsoonafterwardsengaged。ThewingofAristeus,withtheCorinthiansandotherpickedtroopsroundhim,routedthewingopposedtoit,andfollowedforaconsiderabledistanceinpursuit。ButtherestofthearmyofthePotidaeansandofthePeloponnesianswasdefeatedbytheAthenians,andtookrefugewithinthefortifications。Returningfromthepursuit,Aristeusperceivedthedefeatoftherestofthearmy。Beingatalosswhichofthetworiskstochoose,whethertogotoOlynthusortoPotidaea,heatlastdeterminedtodrawhismenintoassmallaspaceaspossible,andforcehiswaywitharunintoPotidaea。Notwithoutdifficulty,throughastormofmissiles,hepassedalongbythebreakwaterthroughthesea,andbroughtoffmostofhismensafe,thoughafewwerelost。MeanwhiletheauxiliariesofthePotidaeansfromOlynthus,whichisaboutsevenmilesoffandinsightofPotidaea,whenthebattlebeganandthesignalswereraised,advancedalittlewaytorenderassistance;andtheMacedonianhorseformedagainstthemtopreventit。ButonvictoryspeedilydeclaringfortheAtheniansandthesignalsbeingtakendown,theyretiredbackwithinthewall;andtheMacedoniansreturnedtotheAthenians。
Thustherewerenocavalrypresentoneitherside。AfterthebattletheAthenianssetupatrophy,andgavebacktheirdeadtothePotidaeansundertruce。ThePotidaeansandtheirallieshadcloseuponthreehundredkilled;theAtheniansahundredandfiftyoftheirowncitizens,andCalliastheirgeneral。
Thewallonthesideoftheisthmushadnowworksatonceraisedagainstit,andmannedbytheAthenians。ThatonthesideofPallenehadnoworksraisedagainstit。TheydidnotthinkthemselvesstrongenoughatoncetokeepagarrisonintheisthmusandtocrossovertoPalleneandraiseworksthere;theywereafraidthatthePotidaeansandtheiralliesmighttakeadvantageoftheirdivisiontoattackthem。MeanwhiletheAtheniansathomelearningthattherewerenoworksatPallene,sometimeafterwardssentoffsixteenhundredheavyinfantryoftheirowncitizensunderthecommandofPhormio,sonofAsopius。ArrivedatPallene,hefixedhisheadquartersatAphytis,andledhisarmyagainstPotidaeabyshortmarches,ravagingthecountryasheadvanced。Nooneventuringtomeethiminthefield,heraisedworksagainstthewallonthesideofPallene。SoatlengthPotidaeawasstronglyinvestedoneitherside,andfromtheseabytheshipsco-operatingintheblockade。Aristeus,seeingitsinvestmentcomplete,andhavingnohopeofitssalvation,exceptintheeventofsomemovementfromthePeloponnese,orofsomeotherimprobablecontingency,advisedallexceptfivehundredtowatchforawindandsailoutoftheplace,inorderthattheirprovisionsmightlastthelonger。Hewaswillingtobehimselfoneofthosewhoremained。Unabletopersuadethem,anddesirousofactingonthenextalternative,andofhavingthingsoutsideinthebestposturepossible,heeludedtheguardshipsoftheAtheniansandsailedout。
RemainingamongtheChalcidians,hecontinuedtocarryonthewar;
inparticularhelaidanambuscadenearthecityoftheSermylians,andcutoffmanyofthem;healsocommunicatedwithPeloponnese,andtriedtocontrivesomemethodbywhichhelpmightbebrought。
Meanwhile,afterthecompletionoftheinvestmentofPotidaea,PhormionextemployedhissixteenhundredmeninravagingChalcidiceandBottica:someofthetownsalsoweretakenbyhim。